I’m guessing this is the pre-print hype cycle, so the doi is correct but not “active” yet.

there is no evidence of that happening. we know that engines did not get fuel. the other pilot asked first pilot if they cut of the fuel, and they replied that i did not (from the black box recordings afaik).

https://aaib.gov.in/What’s New Assets/Preliminary Report VT-ANB.pdf

The aircraft achieved the maximum recorded airspeed of 180 Knots IAS at about 08:08:42 UTC and immediately thereafter, the Engine 1 and Engine 2 fuel cutoff switches transitioned from RUN to CUTOFF position one after another with a time gap of 01 sec. The Engine N1 and N2 began to decrease from their take-off values as the fuel supply to the engines was cut off

That is from the flight data recorder. The switches were moved.

In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots is heard asking the other why did he cutoff. The other pilot responded that he did not do so.

the other pilot asked first pilot if they cut of the fuel,

The other pilot asked WHY they cut the fuel, not IF they had done so.

I stand by my original comment. We only know

1. Two pilots
2. One cut the fuel
3. One restored fuel

That is likely all we will ever know. But the signs point to intentional action to disable the ship.

Air India Tragedy | The Pilots Tried to Save the Airplane

I’ve watched the video, he dismisses the AAIB preliminary report speed data as incorrect, THEN uses that same data to establish his theory about the engines. You can’t have your cake and eat it too, you have to either use the data, or not use the data.

Mr Sabin assumes both pilots are of the same mind and any attempt to not crash shows the lack of self-sabatoge. Imagine a depressed pilot letting their intrusive thoughts win, just for a moment, and switch the fuel cutoff switches… They are likely in shock, not believing what they have done. The other pilot goes into OH SHIT, SURVIVE mode, and the first pilot doesn’t resist, or gets snapped back into reality and works together to try to save the craft. Many self destructive events are snap ephemeral decisions, its not impossible (suicidal people often call emergency services after doing self harm), so Mr. Sabin needs to account for this dynamic as well and not make assumptions about pilot mental unity. Heroic efforts to survive do not remove the potential of intentional action as the root cause.

We will never know the mental state of the pilots, we will only know what was recorded in the black box. The moment in time has passed, and the best outcome we can hope for is the normalization of mental health care for airline crew.

Mr Sabin’s theory about a coverup could be credible, except wouldn’t it be in AAIB’s best interests to throw the responsibility on the plane and not the pilots? Why would they lie about the fuel switch data?

https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2500006122

But the link is broken. Via https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-08-discovery-analgesic-pain-relief-downsides.html

See something, say something.

I just picked up Tametsi based on your recommendation, its super addictive, thank you!

A pilot turned off the fuel.

A pilot tried to save the airplane

There are two pilots in the aircraft

This we know. Everything else is speculation

The video has already been removed from YouTube

No such resource exists just on snoring. It’s not a major health concern (sleep apnea is) so not much gets published specifically on subclinical snoring. I’m synthesizing from my collected knowledge and commenting casually here.

• Ectopic Fat is fat someplace it shouldn’t be
• The human body does not want fat in places it shouldn’t be (intermuscular, interorgan, visceral, airway)
• visceral fat is quicky resolved on a ketogenic intervention (not the only way to resolve, but it is demonstrated in all the literature on NAFLD)
• Anecdotal repots of snoring and sleep apnea resolving on keto

Ketogenic -1.3.9.1.4 How hyperinsulinaemia produces the visceral obesity that is the key to the pathology of the insulin resistance syndrome - This is probably the most relevant thing to read with respect to ectopic fat

As far as the mechanism of action of why carbohydrates are driving ectopic fat please read - The Carbohydrate-Insulin Model of Obesity - Beyond “Calories In, Calories Out” - 2018

Your not asking people to justify with references the “snoring is normal and healthy” vibe that is upvoted here. I think that speaks to the poor metabolic health we have come to accept in society

It’s not really reasonable to expect someone to dig through all of that.

This is the third time now. I keep seeing you blame carbs as the main culprit for various health issues people have. It would be nice to see some primary sources to back it up.

To be fair, your statement was very general “various health issues” and “primary sources”. The only possible response to satisfy that would be all the primary sources on all issues.

Great prompt, I haven’t complied a list of ketogenic reading yet, I’ve rectified that now.

https://hackertalks.com/post/14461366

All the primary resources I’ve read on keto

In practice, a good chunk of the population does snore.

I totally agree with this statement, its very common in the current population.

However, it’s not healthy, so it isn’t normal in so far as normal implies healthy.

that doctor who told John Green it’s not normal to sneeze

How many times have you sneezed today? Do you often sneeze with no stimulating cause? I watched the video, and while the doctor’s statement is reported without nuance (Mr Green didn’t speak with the doctor, he interviewed someone who spoke to a doctor many years ago and that was their recollection), I think it is a valid diagnostic question especially for a allergist or immunologist to use. FWIW I have only sneezed with some stimulating cause, and not “out of the blue”, to the best of my recollection. I think it’s reasonable for a doctor in the context of a diagnostic conversation to say “I never sneeze” leaving out the implicit (without stimulation) to try to coax out patient experiences by illustrating their importance. How about you?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snoring

Snoring is an abnormal breath sound caused by partially obstructed, turbulent airflow and vibration of tissues in the upper respiratory tract (e.g., uvula, soft palate, base of tongue) which occurs during sleep.

You have 4 trainers. Just rotate in a different trainer that can match your schedule.

The fact you prepay has removed all urgency from them. If your trainer is late don’t do the session, don’t pay for the session, just do a solo workout.

They have demonstrated a habit, if you accept it (pay for it) they won’t change.

More generally, one off events are no big deal, remember the human and all that. It’s the pattern that is the issue.

Lots of people smoke. Lots of people go to the gym. There is going to be a overlap.

The fact she is posting about smoking at the gym indicates this is some type of rage baiting.

People can work out for lots of reasons and still do unhealthy things in the rest of their life.

To be fair, he didn’t rush in, he put in the work!

So he must be doing a good Jobs, that is to say Tim isn’t cooked.

update (i couldn’t resist): If he is working, let Tim cook.

VP in finance doesn’t mean anything. Everyone is a VP. Headline should read: someone who worked for a financial firm got a correspondence PhD in prison

He got exonerated, but nobody he know from 19 years ago wants to be associated with him

https://github.com/db0/threativore

Nice to see wgows make it to hn

Uwu, its sooooooo cut. They’re magestic horns; and the lux fur, et al. Their snaggle teeth, that pacific one, is just hte peice of resistance!

There can be physical problems that cause snoring, your right there are many variables, but its not normal.

The problem with “strict diet” is it doesn’t account for metabolic health. There are many unhealthy diets out there, one feature of which can be misplaced fat. For instance there are many professional athletes with T2D.

It’s less common for young people to snore, so its a indicator there is a underlying metabolic issue they can address (if they care to). Think of snoring as subclinical sleep apnea (for illustrative purposes only), there is a spectrum of airway obstruction - you can go quite far down that spectrum without suffering major effects, but its a indicator of less then ideal metabolic health.

Filtering out any chunky bits from the cooking so it doesn’t go back into the fat jar