• 0 Posts
  • 10 Comments
Joined 19 days ago
cake
Cake day: July 17th, 2025

help-circle




  • Just the case of the packages being removed only a few hours after been published just makes my point of “trusted users” reviewing and reporting then.

    And is not only an archlinux/AUR problem, the same happens with python pip, npm, dockerhub, github… With bigger popularity, bigger the target.

    These days after the success of Steamdeck many users switched to Linux, and many of those started using arch or based distros like EndeavourOS because some one on reddit, YouTube or other said is the best for new hardware and you can find everything you need on AUR.
    New users won’t review scripts or PKGBUILD, that’s gibberish, just search and install, and a few hours could be too late for some.

    I don’t care if Linux loses or gains popularity, but if there’s no guard rails of some kind of control things could get worse, and even end AUR as it is now.

    Having people control what’s published or not, probably not the best solution, but leaving it as a wild west also not


  • Arch also warns uses about AUR, use at at your own risk, and can break your system.

    My approach isn’t definitely not the best solution, I was saying this is only the beginning, and with other arch based distros also using AUR only gets worse, if there’s any moderation and some kind of package control before publishing then when thins get real bad maybe too late and arch starts loosing users.

    Now is just some packages, later could be some popular package take overs or some kinda spoofing of other packages.

    I use arch BTW (since 2011), and Debian Armbian on Raspberry Pi, one is rock solid the other sometimes break with updates


  • Is it?

    Android uses Apache License 2.0, which means vendors can modify and distribute without publishing their modifications, like include proprietary blobs and other proprietary code.

    It’s like using Google Chrome instead of Chromium.

    Yes you can debloat the system, but many system apps can’t be disabled without breaking the system, and ROMs based on AOSP the code can be reviewed or modified and built it yourself.

    Xiaomi and mostly stock ROMs these days come bundled with ads, and apps that collect user data, even with debloat or DNS blackhole isn’t 100% private or better than a custom ROM.
    That’s why Graphene and CalyxOS exist.


  • That’s why you shouldn’t blindly trust AUR, and always review the scripts before installing.

    But something needs to change:

    • packages need to be reviewed (maybe also updates on new/untrusted users)
    • New package adoption need to be reviewed
    • Trusted users don’t need package review
    • Trusted users can review new packages (from other users)

    This won’t stop here, more malware packages will appear, arch and Linux in general is getting more users and becoming a target, not only ArchLinux AUR but also other distros with custom repositories. Many users install packages from custom repositories blindly, or follow guides without any knowledge what they do.

    2025 is the year of malware on Linux